By Dr. Ray Spragley, DVM · Updated November 2026
Chronic pain is one of the hardest things to judge in a dog you love. Dogs rarely cry out the way people expect. Pain tends to show up quietly, in small changes that are easy to explain away as old age.
In my experience, the question of when it’s time often comes down to one thing: can your dog’s pain be controlled? Below I’ll walk through how pain shows itself, what good pain management looks like, and how to tell when treatment is no longer enough.
Chronic pain is one of the hardest things to judge in a dog you love. Dogs rarely cry out the way people expect. Pain tends to show up quietly, in small changes that are easy to explain away as old age.
In my experience, the question of when it’s time often comes down to one thing: can your dog’s pain be controlled? Below I’ll walk through how pain shows itself, what good pain management looks like, and how to tell when treatment is no longer enough.
Pain that isn’t controlled can show up in many ways, and it’s often subtle. Things I see families overlook include:
Any one of these on its own can have other causes, which is why they’re worth bringing to your veterinarian. Together, and especially when they’re getting worse, they usually mean your dog is hurting more than you might think. My guide to senior dog panting at night goes into more detail on what nighttime panting can mean.
When a dog is in pain, the goal is to actually relieve that pain, not just make your dog sleepy. A dog who is heavily sedated may look calm, but that isn’t the same as being comfortable. It’s worth talking openly with your veterinarian about whether your dog’s pain is truly being managed.
One way I suggest thinking about it is to imagine the same condition in a person. What would a doctor prescribe for that level of pain? Would that person be hospitalized? If the answer is “a lot more than my dog is getting,” that’s an important conversation to have.
Good pain control is usually multimodal, meaning it uses more than one type of treatment at once, because different medications work on different kinds of pain.
Osteosarcoma, a bone cancer, is one of the most painful conditions dogs get. A dog with osteosarcoma who is only on an anti-inflammatory (NSAID) and gabapentin does not have adequate pain control. Bone cancer pain usually needs stronger, layered treatment. If that level of pain control can’t be achieved, it’s time to begin end-of-life discussions.
Consider a dog with intervertebral disc disease (IVDD) and severe arthritis. Gabapentin and acupuncture may really help the spinal nerve pain, and an NSAID should help the arthritis. That combination can work well for a while.
Over time, though, it may no longer cover all the pain. At that point additional pain medications should be added. If the pain still isn’t covered, it’s time to start talking about end of life.
Pain medication is only helping if your dog actually feels better overall. If the medications control the pain but make your dog miserable, that isn’t a good trade.
Some common side effects of pain medications include:
Your veterinarian may be able to adjust doses or switch medications. But when every combination either leaves your dog in pain or makes them feel unwell, that’s an important sign that their quality of life is slipping.
Many families tell me they feel guilty about the idea of choosing euthanasia “too early.” I understand that feeling. One thing I ask owners to do is put themselves in their dog’s position. Would you want to live the way your dog is living right now?
Being in constant pain is demoralizing. It wears down your dog’s interest in food, play, and the people they love. Choosing to spare your dog from pain that can’t be relieved is not giving up on them.
If you’re unsure whether your dog’s pain is under control, start with your veterinarian and ask directly whether there is more that can be done. The quality of life scale can help you track how your dog is doing over time, and my guide How Will I Know When It’s Time? walks through the questions families most often ask.
If your dog’s chronic illness is cancer, heart disease, or dementia, my guides to lymphoma in dogs, congestive heart failure in dogs, and dog dementia cover the specific signs to watch for with each. And if you’d like help weighing where your dog is, we offer in-home quality of life consultations in New York City and Westchester County.
This article is general information and is not a substitute for an exam by your own veterinarian.
About the author
Dr. Ray Spragley, DVM
Dr. Ray is the veterinarian and owner of Zen Dog Veterinary Care. He earned his veterinary degree from Ross University School of Veterinary Medicine, completed his clinical training at The Ohio State University, and has been in practice for more than a decade. His work today is devoted to in-home euthanasia and quality of life consultations for dogs and cats in New York City and Westchester County.